Pennville Pirates

Pennville is a small town in Penn Township, Jay County, Indiana with a total area of just 0.5 square miles with a population of right around 700 people. Even though he lives in the fictional town of Hawkins, Indiana, Dustin was spotted wearing a Pennville Pirates t-shirt in season 2, so one might assume that it could be located not too far away from Pennville.

Pennville Pirates 1984 Vintage Men’s T-Shirt